Use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in assessments
The misuse of AI in NCFE assessments poses a significant risk and can result in investigation and disqualification. On this page you can find guidance on NCFE’s approach to AI use in assessments.
Not all AI use is misuse.
AI misuse is defined as AI use which signifies a lack of independence or acknowledgment.
AI misuse includes:
- Direct copying – submitting work which is copied or paraphrased from AI-generated content.
- Using AI to analyse or evaluate work – uploading all or part of an assessment and asking AI to review the work.
- Unauthorised assistance – using AI tools to help with tasks which are directly related to assessment objectives. For example, if a learner is being assessed on structure of an essay, then AI must not be used to help structure the essay. Assessment objectives must be demonstrated independently by the learner.
- Non-disclosure – not disclosing the use of AI tools in the creation of submitted work.
- Not verifying information – using information from generative AI without checking sources are accurately reflected.
NCFE is aligned with JCQ in this matter. For more detailed information and examples of misuse, please see the JCQ guidance.
Key principles for learner use of AI in NCFE assessments:
- AI is often not allowed at all. Each assessment has its own rules in the specification and Qualification Specific Instruction Document that must be followed.
- Where AI use is permitted, learners must still independently demonstrate their achievement of each learning outcome.
- Where not part of the learning objectives being assessed, AI can be used for:
- ideation
- planning
- structuring
- decision-making
- translating
- spelling and grammar checking.
- Learners who use AI for any purpose must acknowledge this use.
We have created a set of case studies on AI use and AI misuse in assessment in specific NCFE assessment contexts. These are intended to complement the case studies available in the JCQ guidance.
The table below outlines the broad approach that applies to different NCFE assessment types.
|
|
Invigilated external assessmentFor example:
|
Supervised controlled assessmentFor example:
|
Independent self-study internal assessmentFor example:
|
|
What this assessment is |
A paper-based or online exam. A face-to-face or online professional discussion. |
A project or assignment carried out in controlled conditions. |
Unsupervised coursework and other forms of evidence forming a portfolio. |
|
Is AI use allowed? |
AI use in these assessment types is not allowed. |
If internet access is not allowed for the assessment, no AI use is allowed. If internet access is allowed for the assessment, AI use is allowed as listed above. Learners should produce evidence that is their own work and acknowledges AI use. You must check the Qualification Specific Instruction Document to see what is or isn’t allowed. |
Some AI use is allowed as listed above. Learners should produce evidence that is their own work and acknowledges AI use. |
|
Rationale for use / no use of AI |
These are knowledge-based assessments and must be completed without AI assistance. This includes all apps and tools including AI note takers or any other passive AI assistance. |
These assessments try to mirror the real-world therefore, assessments may allow the use of additional support tools, including AI, in the same way employees would access them in their work. If permitted, learners must produce evidence to support learning outcomes independently. |
These assessments try to mirror the real-world therefore, it may be possible to use some additional support tools, including AI, in the same way employees would access them in their work. Learners must produce evidence to support learning outcomes independently. |
|
Acknowledgment of AI use |
No acknowledgement is required because no AI use is allowed. |
Learner work must be their own. All use of tools, resources and references must be included in the submission as per section 5 of the JCQ guidelines. Learners must include screenshots of the prompts and outputs used with a brief explanation of how AI has been used. Where AI generated content is used directly in the assignment, this should be referenced in the normal way. |
Learner work must be their own. All use of tools, resources and references must be included in the reference list as per section 5 of the JCQ guidelines. Learners must include screenshots of the prompts and outputs used with a brief explanation of how AI has been used. Where AI generated content is used directly in the assignment, this should be referenced in the normal way. |
|
Example assessments |
|
|
|
|
How centres should act |
For online exams, support for centres on how to set up devices and disable access to apps and sites that are not allowed can be found in our guidance on online assessment. If there is any suspected AI use during external assessments, the centre must complete a learner malpractice form. |
The management we expect from our centres is in line with JCQ guidance, where you can find further information and support. The JCQ guidance explains how markers should ensure that learners are demonstrating independent thinking. If AI misuse is suspected the centre must complete a learner malpractice form. |
The management we expect from our centres is in line with JCQ guidance, where you can find further information and support. The JCQ guidance explains how markers should ensure that learners are demonstrating independent thinking. If AI misuse is suspected during these assessments, the centre must follow their malpractice policy. |
We have produced a number of case study examples to support you in how to apply this approach.
We understand that this is a rapidly evolving area with many nuances. Please get in touch via our Customer Support team if you have any specific concerns.